Two AI companion products with confusingly similar names but different positions. SecretDesires.AI is fantasy-narrative-focused with DreamAI SRL Romania operator and the May 2026 audit finding that pricing is single Premium tier (not three tiers as some aggregator sites claim). Secrets.AI is privacy-focused with Private Mode E2E encryption, AI training opt-out, and three-tier structure with published memory metrics (4x/6x access, ~67%/+100% recall percentages).
SecretDesires.AI vs Secrets.AI
Which AI Girlfriend App Is Better? Side-by-side comparison of features, ratings, and value.
··✓ Fact-checked May 12, 2026
SecretDesires.AI
8.7/10
VS
Secrets.AI
8.4/10
Key Metrics Comparison
| SecretDesires.AI | Secrets.AI | |
|---|---|---|
| Editor Rating | 8.7/10 | 8.4/10 |
| User Rating | ★ 4.0/5 (4) | ★ 3.3/5 (2) |
| NSFW Level | Explicit NSFW, Roleplay Focused | companion-focused, mixed-sfw-nsfw |
| Pricing | Freemium, Subscription ($9.99/mo) | Freemium, Subscription ($13.33/mo) |
| Free Trial | ✗ No | ✓ Yes |
| Platforms | Web | Web |
| Features | Custom Characters, NSFW Roleplay | Custom Characters |
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
Character Diversity
SecretDesires.AI
Chat Experience
Tie
NSFW & Roleplay
SecretDesires.AI
Customization
SecretDesires.AI
Media Capabilities
Secrets.AI
Pricing & Value
SecretDesires.AI
Overall
SecretDesires.AI
When SecretDesires.AI Is Better
DreamAI SRL Romania operator (verified EU entity, shared family with DreamGF/DreamBF/JustPorn)
Single Premium tier pricing (May 2026 audit corrected aggregator claims of 3 tiers)
Fantasy-narrative-focused experience over media generation
$9.99/mo entry with straightforward subscription mechanics
Vendor disclosure of family relationships transparent
When Secrets.AI Is Better
Private Mode E2E encryption + AI training opt-out (strongest privacy in audited category)
Published memory metrics: 4x access Premium, 6x Ultimate (rare transparency)
Recall percentages published: ~67% Premium, +100% Ultimate
Group Chats with 2-3 companions (Ultimate-only, unique structural feature)
Three-tier structure with progressive Moments allocation (0/8000/15000)
Our Verdict
Choose SecretDesires.AI if you want guided fantasy scenarios with verified EU operator. SecretDesires runs under the DreamAI SRL Romania family (shared with DreamGF.AI, DreamBF, and JustPorn.ai), with single Premium tier pricing (not three as some aggregator sites claim). The May 2026 audit confirmed the single-tier structure.
Choose Secrets.AI if conversation privacy is your priority. Secrets.AI publishes Private Mode with E2E encryption and AI training opt-out - the strongest documented privacy posture in the AI companion category. Three tiers (Free / Premium $19.99/mo or $13.33/mo annual / Ultimate $39.99/mo or $26.67/mo annual) with published memory multipliers and recall percentages.
These products have similar names but very different positioning. SecretDesires.AI is fantasy-narrative-focused with verified operator transparency. Secrets.AI is privacy-conscious with documented tier metrics. For most users the choice depends on whether narrative depth or privacy posture matters more.
SecretDesires.AI was in the May 2026 audit; the single-Premium-tier finding was the key audit correction against aggregator pricing claims. Secrets.AI was outside the audit scope (vendor wiki pricing only). For users where conversation privacy is the primary feature, Secrets.AI's Private Mode is the most differentiated framework in the AI companion category. See the full May 2026 pricing audit.
📝 Last updated
May 11, 2026. Comparison refreshed with the May 2026 nine-app pricing audit data and v3 review series cross-references. See our review index for the underlying individual reviews.
Editorial Transparency
This comparison is based on hands-on testing of both platforms. Feature and pricing data verified against official sources as of April 2026.
